The nichrome wire extruder heater on my Repstrap finally died after working really fine for over a month ( and being dipped completely in molten plastic a few times, thanks to a few z axis adjustment blunders…) .
It was time to switch to an aluminum heater block/ vitrous resistor combo for much improved reliability and longevity!
It was surprisingly easy and well worth it in the end: it is just NOT possible to have a long term reliable heater with nichrome wire, as:

  1. the windings will always come out differently (so every rewiring will be different, and require recalibration)
  2. it can be hard to attach it to the heater barrel
  3. it degrades with time (seems to ge brittle and sometimes snap)
  4. it cannot be soldered !

So here is a step by step building/assembly guide in case anyone needs it:

General notes:

  1. I used a special drill that drills and taps at the same time: while it might be slightly more expensive than the usual drill heads, its really way more practical than using seperate drills and taps.
  2. I used two vitrous, 3W, 6.8 ohm resistors

So the construction itself:

  • first : mark the hole placements
  • drill/ tap the main hole

    Flickr Tag Error: Call to display photo '5258252671' failed.

    Error state follows:

    • stat: fail
    • code: 95
    • message: SSL is required
  • drill the mounting holes ( this might no be necessary if you already have an insulator block)

    Flickr Tag Error: Call to display photo '5258253951' failed.

    Error state follows:

    • stat: fail
    • code: 95
    • message: SSL is required
  • drill the holes for the the resistor(s) :

    Flickr Tag Error: Call to display photo '5263509352' failed.

    Error state follows:

    • stat: fail
    • code: 95
    • message: SSL is required
    In some of these pictures you can see only one place for a resistor, but after some tests it turned out that it wasn’t quite sufficient, as getting to around 180 C took over 7 minutes (yikes, indeed) and the heater could not go beyond that!! I blame it on the rather large block I used: more surface area means more useless heat dissipation! Adding a second resistor in parallel solved both of these issues completely.
  • if you choose, and your heater block’s size allows for it, you can also drill an additional hole for the thermistor, or you can put it closer to the nozlle and paste it in place with Kapton tape
  • i also did some counter sinking for the attachment screws in order not to have them stick out too much near the bottom of the block,and interfere with printing

    Flickr Tag Error: Call to display photo '5258257295' failed.

    Error state follows:

    • stat: fail
    • code: 95
    • message: SSL is required
  • cut the aluminium block to size ( I usually do it after the drilling, as the final block is relatively small, and maintaining it while drilling would not be practical)

    Flickr Tag Error: Call to display photo '5258260121' failed.

    Error state follows:

    • stat: fail
    • code: 95
    • message: SSL is required
  • mount the block on the isolator/ barrel assembly: since the central hole is already taped, it screws right in!

    Flickr Tag Error: Call to display photo '5263509664' failed.

    Error state follows:

    • stat: fail
    • code: 95
    • message: SSL is required
  • put the resistor(s) and thermistor in place, and attach the resistor’s leads together if you use more than one. Then, solder the cables to the leads of the resistor(s) and  remember to take the different cables final positioning into account

    Flickr Tag Error: Call to display photo '5262898323' failed.

    Error state follows:

    • stat: fail
    • code: 95
    • message: SSL is required
  • be careful to isolate the soldered ends from the block, preferably with kapton tape to have both electric and thermal isolation

    Flickr Tag Error: Call to display photo '5258262009' failed.

    Error state follows:

    • stat: fail
    • code: 95
    • message: SSL is required
  • do the same with the thermistor ( put in place, solder, isolate), it migt also be a good idea to attach the cables to the isolator:

    Flickr Tag Error: Call to display photo '5263508814' failed.

    Error state follows:

    • stat: fail
    • code: 95
    • message: SSL is required

And there you go, one finished heater block ! I had never done one before and it took me less than hour from start to finish so as i like to say “if i can do it ,anybody can do it “:)
Now you can connect, test and calibrate it : very important to go through the printing callibration process again, as a new heater will behave differently, it took me an afternoon to adjust my Skeeinforge setting to get back to the level of quality i had before .

And then , use the new heater, and  watch your house go up in flames! Joking of course, the heater block approach is no more no less dangerous than the one using nichrome wire!

The brand new heater beeing used to print a “Huxley” Reprap vertex (foot if you will) : it works!

Flickr Tag Error: Call to display photo '5263071317' failed.

Error state follows:

  • stat: fail
  • code: 95
  • message: SSL is required
Share and Enjoy:
  • Identi.ca
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Reddit
  • Digg
  • Print
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Add to favorites

Tagged on:                             

2 thoughts on “Repstrap/reprap: from nichrome wire to heater block

    • June 17, 2011 at 01:05
      Permalink

      Hello !
      The nichrome wire was used under less than ideal circumstance, and in very “diy” mode : the only thing holding the wire in place on the hot end was the tension of the windings themselves, as i could never find a way to properly secure it in place.
      Also , i doubt that the nichrome wire enjoyed being “dipped” in plastic a few times 🙂
      I am still using it for a “hot bed” configuration where it is still working after a few months of service.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.